You’re Kidding—Forgive How Many Times?
Comfort Cafe Subscribers, You can access the main site by clicking “home” on the left hand menu or “Comfort Cafe Magazine and Resources.”
If your loved one sins, rebuke him, and if he repents, forgive him. If he sins against you seven times in a day, and seven times comes back to you and says, ‘I repent,’ forgive him (Luke 17:3-4, my paraphrase substituting “loved one” for “brother”).
Frankly, this verse really makes me uncomfortable on a couple of levels. First, I’m to rebuke my brother or sister? That’s not very nice. Isn’t it more Christ-like to put on a meek spirit and suffer quietly? Apparently not. Hmmmm…
Jesus forces me to face my resistance to confrontation. I prefer to retain my “nice girl” image. At all costs, I desperately want to be liked.
But Jesus’ way is psychologically brilliant. Stuffing feelings feeds resentment, yet this toxic buildup often drains away when we find the courage to confront. Speaking up empowers us, regardless of the other person’s response.
Next I find myself puzzled by Jesus’ statement, “And if your loved one repents, forgive him.” I want to say, “Wait, Jesus, that sounds pretty conditional to me. I’ve always thought we were supposed to forgive whether the other person is sorry for what they’ve done or not!”
But then Jesus describes what this repentance looks like. My girlfriend can come to me seven times a day and simply say, “I repent,” and I’m supposed to forgive her. Seven times a day? For how long? I’m sorry, but mine and Jesus’ definition of repentance clash. Suddenly I can no longer relegate forgiveness to simply a warm and fuzzy idea. This seven times a day business would quickly find me with my hands on my hips and a scowl on my face.
“You can’t possibly mean you’re sorry again,” I’d say in a harsh tone of voice. “There’s no way you’d keep doing the same thing over and over knowing how much it hurts me. This isn’t true repentance!”
“But I am really sorry…”
I’d shake my head in disbelief. “Sure you are. I swear, you’re just taking advantage of me.”
Maybe you, like me, have spent hours trying to analyze “true repentance.” But doesn’t a little voice keep whispering, What about the countless times you’ve come to your Heavenly Father, ashamed that once again you failed in your chronic weakness? Has He ever said to you, “Sorry, that’s not true repentance—you’re taking advantage of me”?
Praise God His grace extends an eternity farther than ours!
According to Jesus, rebuke, repentance, and forgiveness work together to create harmonious relationships. The Bible does teach that we are to forgive others whether they are repentant or not. However, in these verses in Luke Jesus seems to be giving specific instructions for relating to people who desire to be close to us.
If we humbly speak up about how we feel when we’re offended, we give our loved one the opportunity to make things right and avoid the cesspool of resentment. But if we’re too cowardly to exercise this God-given safety valve, we will, in many cases, needlessly struggle with anger and bitterness.
And if we remember how God continually forgives us far more than we are called upon to forgive others, we will grow in mercy and compassion each time a brother or sister expresses sorrow about their failure.
Rebuke, repentance and forgiveness. Exercised within the circle of humble honesty, our relationships will flourish.
Lord, we are so far from being like you. Give us the courage to rebuke in truth, and give us a heart like yours, willing to extend love, grace, and mercy over and over again.





